Read WebProNews
With Friends!

Google’s Dominance and Microsoft’s Perseverance

Is Google Just Unstoppable?

Get the WebProNews Newsletter!
Top Rated White Papers and Resources
There are 60 Comments. Add Yours.
  1. empirestatebuddy

    i use Vista, Explorer, Office and… Google. why? because, in the past, Google was better. maybe they’re equal (now), but as Crum points out… why change? Microsoft and Yahoo need to give consumers a reason to switch… a very good reason. just as Google has to give us a good reason to switch to Android or Chrome…

  2. That’s some very clear thinking about the horserace and I think you can draw conclusions for a lot of other segments on the Internet from it.

    Particularly the fact that users cannot tell the difference in the results… because, there certainly are differences. What do you make of that contradiction?

    – Eric

    • Chris Crum

      Frankly, I just wonder how controlled these results were.

  3. C

    I just get the sense that Microsoft knows it needs Yahoo and Carol Bartz is more schrewd than Jerry Yang. As this market seems to get stronger it makes sense for Ballmer to make another bid at a little less than his original offer to save face with shareholders and Carol will be wise to take it as a huge premium to its current $13.47 stock price. The longer Microsoft waits the more they will pay if the market keeps rebounding. This deal gets done this weekend, my prediction.

  4. You certainly are right about Microsft should use their brand name and I don’t think live.com can attract visitors the way microsoft.com can. Yahoo is definitely striving hard and I think they will soon reap the fruits of their efforts, as for Google, I don’t see it making any ‘BIG’ mistake in near future.

  5. I don’t think it’s about the ‘name’ as much as it’s the ‘algorithm’ implemented by the ‘big three’ in the search engine market.

    For example, search for any keyword within the 3 engines and see how sometimes it’s totally different how the same page included in the results. Till now, google almost fetch the stuff and don’t forget about the PageRank; something that every webmaster care about!

    • Chris Crum

      You’ve got to consider that most Google users aren’t necessarily webmasters though.

      • For sure, Chris. That’s why I mentioned how searching a keyword via the big three might show up different results in positioning.

  6. i like these stats and i agree completely with your post google is becoming the master of search over the web,yes google is unstoppable rather uncompetitive.it is believed by some experts that google may capture all the big divas in the market.

    • Guest

      I integrated Google serch on my site http://www.moscowbeauties.ru It works very nice. But unfortunately it doesnt work with russian leters. But with latin latters it show the best results of searching. As for me, first of all I seach something in the Internet with the help of russian Yandex search and then Google. Sometimes – Yahoo. Never MSN. But I like Micrisoft’s soft.

      Best wishies from Russia

      http://www.moscowbeauties.ru

  7. Guest

    Microsoft’s biggest hurdle is Ballmer.

  8. I think Google is stoppable if they get changing their algorithms every other week. I’m getting tired of the constantly changing search results. Yahoo provides me with much more reliable results. If their name had become a verb like Googles did, they would have much more market share.

  9. yes i think google is unstoppable until and unless they make a mistake

  10. I think Google is unstoppable! Because most of the internetusers only knows google…

  11. I think that most forget that Google is not just a search engine, but an advertising platform as well.

    Perhaps this is one of the reasons Google remains so strong.

  12. Its hard to see anybody breaking Google’s dominance now, especially in this economic climate.The others must be disappointed they have gone backwards.

  13. Google is a verb – it’s part of the business lexicon like Kleenex and Xerox. Unless some game-changing technology comes along that Google ignores, it’s very hard to imaging Google being usurped by another SE.

  14. Even though Google dominates the search engine industry,It faces tough competition from social book marking sites (digg,reddit,yahoo buzz etc ) and micro blogging sites such as Twitter when it comes in the field of total web traffic. Most of the times Google fails to provide fresh web content but Twitter & Digg can give you real time updates from web world and there is a need of a “Perfect Search engine” which can index the real time stories.Here it is good chance for the rivals of Google(Microsoft & Yahoo) to play some mind game to develop such one.

  15. Guest

    Google is not unstoppable and google does not need to fear Yahoo or microsoft it needs to fear google itself.

    Over the last 18 months google search has become not so great, when doing a search on many subjects the first page is nothing but directories.

    Google is dead against link farms and paid links??

    So what are directories??

    So people get sick of directories they click on the paid links??

    Am I wrong??

    • Guest

      I think you raise a good point. Directories are annoying. As a matter of fact, people will scroll way down past the directories just to find what looks like an honest, organic SE result.

      This is based purely on anecdotal evidence of my own, of course, but it seems to make sense that a better site is one which produces honest content, therefore honest SE results rather than simply a link promoted through an online telephone directory.

      I agree with the article’s premise, which is that Microsoft is having a real identity crisis.

  16. Whaty the article and comment thread shows is that people have been brainwshed into believing google is the best search engine just as they were brainwashed into believing Microsoft DOS years back and later Windows were the best operating systems when neither was at the time the various versions of both were launched.

    The quasi religious qualty of google’s support is shown by the person who says they have the brightest minds on the planet working for them. If the google team were really all that bright they would be able to understand that just because two articles contain the same word it does not mean there is a contextual link.

    We need to get over the idea so careflly seeded by google that the quality of a search engine can be judged by the number of results it throws up (!) I dont’t want a million results I want five or ten relevant results – which is what I get on Alta Vista or Ask.

    http://www.greenteethmm.com/dontbeevil.html

  17. Guest

    Nobody is going to be able to catch Google as long as they continue to operate as they do today. Especially Microsoft. Google uses a lot of open source software (mostly Linux), and develops and contributes a LOT back to the open source community. Because of this, Google has been able to strengthen itself significantly over its competition. Microsoft is so closed-minded and tries to do things its own way, that I don’t see how they will ever be able to grow much more and even think about being a competitor in the future. Time will definitely show us. Thankfully Google recognizes the open source movement and is on board. Open source itself is making a big movement, which I document in more detail myself:

    http://members.apex-internet.com/sa/windowslinux

  18. I’ve noticed that I visit Yahoo more ofen just to read the news items. Perhaps it’s a good idea for live.com as well to become more than just a search box.

  19. As an SEO, I give top priority to Google always. Yes, Yahoo and MSN are important but my clients aren’t blasting me when their MSN rankings drop. But if they slide even a couple of spots on Google, the phone starts ringing. It’s just reality. Look at your analytics and you’ll quickly see your referral traffic sugar daddy is: Google.

  20. I think the most relevant point for Microsoft as stated is too stop confusing the users with so many pointless names and use the search feature as mentioned above on the main Microsoft home page.

  21. Guest

    Your journalism sucks

  22. We really have no need to go into figures. Might it is because of the way google algorithm works. Yahoo and msn gives more importance to page titles but google check for the quality content on the pages. One of my web site related to UK Magazines (http://www.ukmagz.co.uk) is in top 3 position for my main keywords like “UK Magazines” , “UK Magazine” etc. in the Yahoo UK, but Would you believe I only receive 3 to 6 unique visits from yahoo daily. At the same time on google my websites avg position is 15 but I receive 30 to 40 unique visits daily.

    Jawad

  23. Who cares about this? Google is winning, blah, blah, blah. Do you know what kind of coffee you drink, and does it matter to you if they are the dominant player in the market?

    • Guest

      Why are you even on this site?

  24. Guest

    It doesen’t really matter who is #1. We all use the “big 3″ search engines. If I can’t find what I’m looking for on one, I just try another.

    • I don’t agree – i think people will refine there search rather than look at the other 2 search engines.

  25. I Still use google and if i can’t find what i’m looking for on the first page – guess what i look for it on page two – or i refine my search – it wouldn’t cross my mind to use yahoo or msn(live).

    I don’t agree that google will be the number one daddy forever – remember they used to say that about yahoo only this century.

  26. I agree, I don’t believe Google will be on top forever. At this point in time, they are the ‘news’; hence some people gravitate to them.

    Now, if the media starts “recognizing” another with as much fanfare as they have been giving to Google, then probably ??? the internet users might cross-over.

  27. Does anyone learn anything from the past presidential election?
    No, I am not talking politics here.
    What set apart winning team from the others is consitency in the message and being in tune with the people’s need.

    Google is about search and search only. They do not need to be the best. As long as I can find something closed to the solution I am looking for, a website easy to use that does not distract me from my goal then I will go for Google.

    Yahoo is as good as Google but its website is so distracting you wonder what’s their main focus. Microsoft is yet to find its identity as far as the search engine is concerned.

    Users do not have time to guess:
    When I searching general information, I google it
    If I am looking for movies and entertainement schedules I go to Yahoo.
    Microsoft Live Search I still do not know how to do with that. The only times I end up there is when I am tricked to click a link from my hotmail account.

    So until the other two contenders are clear about what service they are offering, the users will go to the strore proudly displying the OPEN FOR BUSINESS sign.

  28. I use Google because it`s simply the best.

  29. Google apostate

    “Guest (WPN reader)” at 8:59 was closest to the mark. We’d relied first and foremost on Google for years for the same reason that they leapfrogged every other search engine / direstory on the web — their ability to spider entire pages in their index and return search results based on relevancy, especially to long-string search queries. But we’ve turned to MSN Live as our first resort since last fall, when Google’s algorithm tweaks began returning garbage results (and failing to return relevant results) based more on “popularity,” paid links, and SEO duplicity rather than relevance to the search query.

    Aside from branding, MSN’s (and Yahoo’s) best bet to stop losing ground to Google is to focus on doing what once made Google great — returning relevant results, without churning up garbage results alongside or ahead of the relevant results. Google’s Image search, however, remains head and shoulders (and hips and knees) ahead of anyone else’s, if only for its streamlined format and ease of use.

  30. toto

    Microsoft will catch up to Google when:

    - MS start teaming up with pantyless celebrities, rappers.
    - Start kissing webmasters’ tails. Providing them the world.
    - Providing relevant results.

    That’s the only way for any Microsoft SE to catch up to Google.

    • Guest

      and also need to change that ugly Live Search name.

What do you think? Respond.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>