Federal safety regulators are investigating comma.ai, the startup that sells plug-in hardware letting ordinary cars steer and brake themselves on the highway, after five crashes in which vehicles using its devices hit stopped or slow-moving cars in their own lane. Two of those crashes killed three people, and four of them injured 11 others, some seriously.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Office of Defects Investigation opened the preliminary evaluation, numbered PE26007, on Monday and posted its opening résumé this week. It covers the comma three, comma 3X and comma four devices and the company’s open-source openpilot software, an estimated 30,000 units in all. The agency said it has confirmed the systems were “powered on or engaged in multiple crashes” and that preliminary data “suggests that the comma system may not have adequately detected or responded to the in-lane vehicles.”
How the devices work
Comma’s devices connect to a car’s existing systems through wire harnesses and pair the device’s own cameras with the car’s stock sensors to control speed and steering. Buyers install them at home. NHTSA’s filing quotes the company’s marketing, which promises “hands free driving for the car you already have,” a 15-minute setup and software that “[c]an drive for hours without intervention,” alongside the site’s warning that “openpilot requires the driver to be alert, pay attention, and be ready to take over at all times.”
The company says more than 30,000 vehicles have logged over 402 million miles on openpilot, Ars Technica reported. Comma was founded in 2015 by George Hotz, who stepped back from day-to-day operations in 2022. Neither the company nor Hotz responded to requests for comment, according to TechCrunch.
The crashes, and the question of forks
One of the fatal crashes appears to have happened in February in Ascension Parish, Louisiana. A 2022 Toyota RAV4 running FrogPilot, a third-party fork of openpilot, struck an unoccupied Gonzales Police Department unit that was parked in the left lane with its emergency lights on while officers handled another crash. Louisiana State Police said two rear-seat passengers in the Toyota died.
Electrek matched four of the five crash report IDs in NHTSA’s public data. Besides the Louisiana case, they include a September 2025 crash in which a 2020 Honda Accord with openpilot engaged rear-ended a stopped car on a Missouri highway at 82 mph, and a July crash near Mona, Utah, where a 2021 Toyota Corolla hit a stopped car at 56 mph. Each of comma’s own reports opens with a disclaimer that it provides the information “without agreeing with NHTSA’s interpretations or conceding that comma is obligated to respond to the General Order,” Electrek found.
Because openpilot is open source, owners can run modified versions that change how the system behaves. NHTSA said that when a fork is involved, it will “consider the shared components between openpilot and the fork.” At least two of the five crashes involved forks, according to Ars Technica.
This isn’t the company’s first brush with the agency. In 2016, NHTSA demanded proof that a planned comma self-driving device would be safe or risk having its sale blocked, and comma said at the time that it was redirecting its efforts to “other products and markets,” Reuters reported. A preliminary evaluation is an early stage. NHTSA has not found a defect, and the review can close without action or be upgraded to an engineering analysis.


WebProNews is an iEntry Publication