Mrs. Doubtfire was a smash hit when it came out in 1993; Robin Williams knew how to work an audience from belly laughs to tears with his impressions and genuine love for his children, and the film went from box office hit to video and DVD success. It’s no surprise, then, that talk of a sequel would come about. What’s surprising is that the sequel is coming 20 years later.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, Chris Columbus is down for a part 2, and so is Williams. Elf writer David Berenbaum is attached to write the script, which has actually been on the table since 2001, when talk of a sequel first began. The script has been through a lot of rewrites, however, and producers haven’t been able to find the right writer for the job.

Williams–who won a Golden Globe for the role–may be up for a new take on the story, but at least two actors from the original film aren’t so sure: Mara Wilson, who played little Natalie, and Lisa Jakub, who played eldest daughter Lydia, have both weighed in on the news this week.

There are many, many reasons I don't want to be in Mrs. Doubtfire 2. But they haven't even asked me (yet), so no need to worry.

— Mara Wilson (@MaraWritesStuff) April 17, 2014

They haven't asked me to be in it, and I think it would be weird if they did! I don't act much and am not a cute little kid anymore.

— Mara Wilson (@MaraWritesStuff) April 17, 2014

The only reason I've SAID I don't want to do it is because of the literal hundreds of people asking me about it.

— Mara Wilson (@MaraWritesStuff) April 17, 2014

I loved being in Doubtfire, and I'm grateful every day I had that experience. I met my sister-for-life Lisa there. I had a great time.

— Mara Wilson (@MaraWritesStuff) April 17, 2014

But I don't think a sequel makes sense plotwise, and I don't think there'd be a part for me even if I did still act and was interested.

— Mara Wilson (@MaraWritesStuff) April 17, 2014

Wilson, a successful writer with a big social media presence who says she doesn’t do much acting these days, is very well known for her childhood performances (she was also in one of the best movies of all time, Matilda) and gets questions about Mrs. Doubtfire pretty frequently. Jacub, who has retired from the acting world, took to Twitter to admit she didn’t know anything about a sequel beforehand and hasn’t been asked to be involved.

About #MrsDoubtfire2 : It's news to me! No one has asked and don't know how I would feel about it. Hard to comment without any information!

— Lisa Jakub (@Lisa_Jakub) April 17, 2014

No word yet on whether Sally Field or Matthew Lawrence will be involved, or how far along the script is.

Image via YouTube