Target’s $5 Billion Gamble: Revamping Stores to End a Four-Year Sales Drought

Target is investing $5 billion in store upgrades, price cuts, and AI integrations to combat a four-year sales slump, with Q3 comparable sales down 2.7%. Incoming CEO Michael Fiddelke prioritizes growth amid economic caution, but holiday prospects remain tepid.
Target’s $5 Billion Gamble: Revamping Stores to End a Four-Year Sales Drought
Written by Zane Howard

Target Corporation is doubling down on a massive investment strategy amid one of its most prolonged sales slumps in recent history. The retailer announced plans to pour an additional $1 billion into store upgrades, merchandise enhancements, and digital improvements next year, pushing total capital expenditures to $5 billion—a 25% increase year-over-year. This move comes as Target reported its 12th consecutive quarter of weak or declining comparable sales, with a 2.7% drop in the three months ended November 1, 2025.

Incoming CEO Michael Fiddelke, set to take the helm on February 1, 2026, emphasized the urgency of returning to growth. “Mission 1 through 10 is to get back to growth for us,” Fiddelke told reporters, as reported by The Wall Street Journal. The investments aim to address shopper complaints about messy stores, out-of-stock items, and lackluster product selections, which have contributed to a 35% decline in Target’s stock this year.

External pressures, including persistent inflation and economic uncertainty, have exacerbated Target’s challenges. Shoppers are prioritizing essentials over discretionary items like home decor and apparel, leading to reduced store visits and lower spending per trip. Fiddelke noted volatility from factors such as pauses in SNAP funding and a government shutdown, which disrupted consumer behavior in the recent quarter.

A Slump That Won’t Quit

Target’s third-quarter net sales fell 1.5% to $25.3 billion, with net income dropping 19% to $689 million. The company revised its full-year profit outlook downward to $7 to $8 per share, from a previous range of $7 to $9. This adjustment reflects ongoing caution among consumers, who are making trade-offs in spending—favoring candy and costumes for Halloween but skimping on seasonal decor, according to Chief Commercial Officer Rick Gomez.

“For the winter holidays, the consumer is likely to give priority to what goes under the tree versus what goes on the tree,” Gomez said in The Wall Street Journal. This sentiment aligns with broader retail trends, where discretionary spending remains soft. Home Depot, for instance, reported a downturn in home-improvement activity, with comparable sales rising only 0.2%—missing forecasts—amid slipping home prices and a wobbly job market.

Target’s struggles are not solely external. The retailer has faced criticism for higher prices compared to competitors like Walmart, Temu, and Shein, which have gained ground during inflationary periods. Self-inflicted issues, such as inventory mismanagement and less compelling merchandise, have alienated its core customer base known for seeking trendy, affordable items.

Strategic Overhaul Under New Leadership

Fiddelke’s vision includes accelerating digital experiences, introducing more novelty and value, and enhancing supply chain reliability. In March 2025, Target outlined plans to drive over $15 billion in sales growth by 2030 through these pillars, as detailed in a press release on its corporate site. However, recent performance has forced a more aggressive approach, including last month’s layoffs of 1,800 corporate jobs—about 8% of its headquarters staff—to reduce complexity and speed decision-making, per CNBC.

The incoming CEO is betting on technology to differentiate Target. A new partnership with OpenAI allows users to browse and add Target products to carts via ChatGPT, with purchases completed on Target’s platform. This AI integration is part of broader tech investments aimed at improving e-commerce and in-store experiences, as Fiddelke highlighted the need for faster, more reliable systems.

Price cuts are another key tactic. Target recently reduced prices on 3,000 everyday products, building on earlier reductions of 5,000 items in May 2025, to attract budget-conscious shoppers. Posts on X (formerly Twitter) from users like KTLA and More Perfect Union noted these moves as efforts to win back customers amid inflation, with some highlighting plans for thousands more cuts ahead of the holidays.

Holiday Hopes and Retail Realities

As the crucial holiday season approaches, Target is positioning itself with trendy exclusives, such as trading cards and ‘Stranger Things’-related products, to spark excitement. Yet, executives warn of a meager holiday outlook, with sales slumps hinting at continued caution. CNBC reported Target gearing up to snap a four-year sales drought, but analysts remain skeptical given the persistent decline.

Broader retail trends underscore the challenges. Coresight Research posts on X indicate that discount retailers are dominating early holiday shopping in 2025, with 13.4% of consumers already finished—up significantly from last year—driven by inflation and potential tariffs. Younger shoppers, including Gen Z and millennials, are tightening budgets amid student loan resumptions and a softer job market, as noted in X posts from elcastilloinvestments.com.

Target’s DEI rollback has also stirred controversy, potentially impacting sales. X posts from attorney Ben Crump and Pop Crave discussed a 200-plus day boycott following the scaling back of diversity initiatives, leading to a $20 billion market value loss and reduced foot traffic. A September 2025 article from Investopedia detailed these effects, including the departure of former CEO Brian Cornell.

Investor Sentiment and Market Pressures

Wall Street’s reaction has been muted. Target’s stock slipped following the Q3 earnings release, as covered by TechStock², with Fiddelke declining to specify when sales might turn positive. X posts from TradeTheNews.com echoed the $5 billion investment announcement, while Brian Sozzi noted Target’s pattern of brutal earnings warnings throughout 2025.

The retailer’s 2024 Annual Report, published in April 2025 on its corporate site, provides context on prior strategies, but the current slump—worsened by a 3.8% Q1 sales drop attributed partly to DEI backlash—demands bold action. Fiddelke’s restructuring, including AI bets and store revamps, aims to reverse this, but success hinges on navigating economic headwinds.

Competitors like Walmart have fared better by emphasizing value, forcing Target to adapt. As Axios reported, Fiddelke is focusing on price cuts and investments post-weak sales, with an eye on Black Friday and beyond. Yet, with consumers hesitant on big commitments, as echoed by Home Depot’s CFO Richard McPhail, Target’s path to recovery remains uncertain.

Long-Term Vision Amid Short-Term Pain

Looking ahead, Target’s March 2025 strategic plan emphasizes digital acceleration and value amplification to differentiate the brand. However, the four-year sales slump, detailed in WWD, shows a 1.5% Q3 decline, prompting the capex boost. Fiddelke’s leadership will be tested in executing these changes while managing costs from layoffs and investments.

Industry insiders note that nostalgia and AI could play roles, with X posts like those from くるみ referencing Target’s bets on cocoa, nostalgia, and AI to turn around the year, per Business Insider. Still, with profit slides signaling a tepid holiday, as in Lufkin Daily News, the retailer must deliver on its promises.

Ultimately, Target’s $5 billion gamble represents a high-stakes pivot. By addressing core issues like store appeal and pricing, while leveraging tech innovations, the company aims to reclaim its position as a go-to for affordable chic. As the retail landscape evolves with economic pressures, Fiddelke’s strategy could either reignite growth or highlight the perils of delayed adaptation.

Subscribe for Updates

RetailPro Newsletter

Strategies, updates and insights for retail professionals and decision makers.

By signing up for our newsletter you agree to receive content related to ientry.com / webpronews.com and our affiliate partners. For additional information refer to our terms of service.

Notice an error?

Help us improve our content by reporting any issues you find.

Get the WebProNews newsletter delivered to your inbox

Get the free daily newsletter read by decision makers

Subscribe
Advertise with Us

Ready to get started?

Get our media kit

Advertise with Us