Former Buffy the Vampire Slayer star Sarah Michelle Gellar took to Twitter to relate her take on Peter Pan Live!, along with various other Hollywood personalities.

Girls actress Allison Williams played the title role in the NBC production, which aired Thursday. The program was watched by 9.1 million viewers, down from the 18.6 millions viewers garnered by NBC’s The Sound of Music Live! last year.

The live special was narrated by Minnie Driver, who was also cast as the adult character Wendy. Christopher Walken played Captain Hook.

Commenting on the role, Williams, 26, said, “To most of America I’m going to be a new face, which is part of what’s exciting about it for me. To those people, I’ll be Peter Pan.”

Gellar chimed in:

Poor #Wendy doesn't she realize she's not #peters type #PeterPanLive – we've all been there honey. It's called #Neverland for a reason

— Sarah Michelle (@RealSMG) December 5, 2014

I mean come on ….the "guy" carries around "fairy dust" #hesjustnotthatintoyou #PeterPanLive

— Sarah Michelle (@RealSMG) December 5, 2014

I wonder what next years live musical will be?? I'm hoping for @MariahCarey in #HelloDolly. Anyone else have any ideas?

— Sarah Michelle (@RealSMG) December 5, 2014

Carrie Underwood, star of The Sound of Music Live! prasied the production:

I hope the cast & crew of #PeterPanLive feel so happy & proud right now! What an incredible thing you all were a part of tonight! Amazing!!!

— Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood) December 5, 2014

Zach Braff is being funny again:

I want Allison Williams as a boy to take my gay virginity. #PeterPanLive

— Zach Braff (@zachbraff) December 5, 2014

Wendy wants Peter's Tink. #PeterPanLive

— Zach Braff (@zachbraff) December 5, 2014

Anna Kendrick got confused:

Watching a grown woman play an adolescent boy is perhaps the most sexually confusing moment of my life. #PeterPanLive

— Anna Kendrick (@AnnaKendrick47) December 5, 2014

Various other celebrity tweets:

Congrats to #PeterPanLive ! So nice to see musicals on TV again. Yay!!!

— Kristin Chenoweth (@KChenoweth) December 5, 2014

I BELIEVE IN YOU ALLISON WILLIAMS!!!

— KATY PERRY (@katyperry) December 5, 2014

Hey #AllisonWilliams, you got this girl! Congrats on a great performance! #PeterPanLive

— backstreetboys (@backstreetboys) December 5, 2014

Now THAT, my friends, was amazing. Hats off to everyone involved and for all you hilarious Twitts cracking me up back stage #PeterPanLive

— Minnie Driver (@driverminnie) December 5, 2014

There are only two women in #PETERPANLIVE and they're both Christopher Walken

— Sarah Silverman (@SarahKSilverman) December 5, 2014

Christopher Walken perform’s “Hook’s Tango”: