Reddit shares closed at $166.28 on April 20, 2026, down 3.72% that day amid fresh doubts over user engagement. The drop echoed a pattern investors know too well. Logged-in user growth came in somewhat disappointing, as noted in the Carillon Eagle Mid Cap Growth Fund Q1 2026 investor letter. Uncertainty swirled around renewals for large language model data-licensing deals. Still, the platform posted solid revenue gains and profitability. It even greenlit a stock buyback. Roughly half its users skip other social sites, making the audience prime for advertisers.
But. Numbers tell the real story. Back in February 2025, Reddit’s Q4 global daily active uniques—or DAUq—hit 101.7 million, up 39% year-over-year yet shy of Wall Street’s 103.1 million call. Shares plunged more than 15%. Revenue soared 71% to $428 million, beating $405 million estimates. Earnings per share landed at 36 cents against 25 cents expected. CEO Steve Huffman pinned the miss on Google’s twice-yearly search tweaks, hitting logged-out users hardest. “What happened wasn’t unusual—referrals from search fluctuate from time to time, and they primarily affect logged-out users,” he said, per CNBC. Traffic rebounded into Q1. Guidance topped forecasts at $360 million to $370 million.
Fast forward to Q4 2025. DAUq grew 19% to 121.4 million globally, edging past 120 million expectations. U.S. DAUq rose 9% to 52.5 million. Logged-in U.S. users? Just 5% growth to 23 million—slower than Q3’s 7%, marking six straight quarters of deceleration. Revenue jumped 70% to $726 million. EPS crushed at $1.24 versus 94 cents forecast. Shares rose 5% after hours initially. Yet the stock has shed 30% over the past year, per Barron’s. Q1 2026 guidance pointed to $595 million-$605 million, above $577 million Street views.
Huffman addressed the split metrics. “As the industry evolves, how we think about our product and users must evolve too,” he told analysts, signaling a phase-out of logged-in versus logged-out breakdowns by late 2026, as reported by CNBC. Finance chief Drew Vollero promised continuity through Q2. Data deals with Google and OpenAI? “Relationships…are very healthy,” Huffman added. Conversations now tilt toward product ties, pulling users deeper into communities.
Investors fixate on logged-in users. They drive ad dollars. Logged-out traffic boosts totals but converts less. Slowing U.S. logged-in growth—down to 5%—stings. Global logged-in DAUq hit 50.2 million in Q3 2025, up 14%, while logged-out surged 24% to 65.8 million. Dependence on Google referrals exposes risks. Algorithm shifts twice yearly. Recovery happens. But misses spark selloffs.
And the stock suffers. Down sharply year-to-date through early 2026. Hedge funds hold steady—82 portfolios at Q4 end, up slightly. Analysts urge buying dips. Morgan Stanley’s Brian Nowak saw value post-2025 miss. Wells Fargo’s Ken Gawrelski stayed overweight, eyeing steady U.S. growth. Bank of America held neutral on valuation and Google reliance.
AI hype fuels Reddit’s pitch. Authentic conversations. Human data goldmine for LLMs. Licensing brought $36 million in Q4 2025—small slice of $726 million. Negotiations ramp for real-time access. Platform tweaks like machine translation span 30 languages. International DAUq jumps 31%. Reddit Answers, AI search, scaled to 15 million weekly users from 1 million.
Free cash flow tripled to $684 million last year. Gross margins topped 90% for six quarters. Cash hoard nears $2.5 billion, zero debt. ARPU climbed 42% to $5.98. Weekly actives reached 471 million, up 24%. Yet sentiment sours on growth deceleration. Piper Sandler stuck with overweight at $205 even as March users dipped seasonally.
Q1 earnings loom April 30. Forward P/E around 33x amid 52-54% guidance. Macro noise drags tech. But Reddit prints money—35% net margins on explosive top-line growth. Network effects lock in users. AI can’t fake raw discourse at scale.
Disappointments mount. Stock tests supports near June 2025 levels. Buyback deploys $1 billion. Fundamentals scream undervalued. Wall Street watches DAUq closely. Next print decides if recovery sticks.
WebProNews is an iEntry Publication