After a tenure marked by declining sales and strategic missteps, John Donahoe is stepping down as Nike’s CEO. The athletic giant announced that Donahoe will retire from his post on October 13, with longtime Nike executive Elliott Hill coming out of retirement to take over the top role. Hill, a 32-year veteran of the company, is expected to steer Nike back to its roots after a period of turbulence under Donahoe’s leadership.

Donahoe’s departure comes at a critical time for Nike. While his leadership saw the company navigate the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, his tenure was also marred by falling revenues and a backlash from both consumers and partners. Nike’s decision to cut ties with key retailers such as Foot Locker and shift towards a direct-to-consumer (DTC) model alienated some loyal customers and sparked concerns among investors.

Listen to our conversation on Nike’s CEO moves. Former execs positive on Elliott Hill:

“John Donahoe’s approach, while well-intentioned, wasn’t what Nike needed in this evolving market,” said a former Nike executive. “The move towards DTC at the expense of wholesale partners created friction and caused us to lose touch with some of the core consumers that made Nike a dominant force.”

Shifting Strategy, Lingering Challenges

Donahoe, who came from a tech and consulting background, was seen as an unconventional choice for Nike’s CEO role when he took over in 2020. His strategy focused heavily on streamlining the company’s operations, cutting costs, and investing in digital transformation. However, critics argue that this approach diminished Nike’s reputation as a leader in fashion and innovation, which had been carefully cultivated over decades.

A key part of Donahoe’s strategy was emphasizing e-commerce and the company’s own digital platforms, a move that some insiders believed was out of step with Nike’s historical strength in brick-and-mortar retail and brand partnerships. His decision to sever ties with Foot Locker, a long-standing retail partner, was met with considerable criticism. As a result, Nike saw its same-store sales slump by 2.9% in the first quarter of 2024.

“E-commerce is crucial, but we lost sight of what made Nike unique,” said one former executive. “Our strength has always been our ability to connect with consumers through partners and tell a compelling brand story. We shifted too far away from that.”

The Return of a Veteran: Elliott Hill

The decision to bring back Elliott Hill, a seasoned Nike executive who retired in 2020, is widely seen as an effort to restore Nike’s standing. Hill, who spent over three decades at the company in various leadership roles, is highly regarded for his deep knowledge of Nike’s culture, its products, and its relationships with partners. As the former President of Consumer and Marketplace, Hill was instrumental in driving growth across Nike and Jordan Brand during his tenure.

“I am excited to welcome Elliott back to Nike,” said Mark Parker, Nike’s executive chairman and former CEO, in a statement. “Given our needs for the future, the past performance of the business, and after conducting a thoughtful succession process, the Board concluded it was clear that Elliott’s global expertise, leadership style, and deep understanding of our industry make him the right person to lead Nike’s next stage of growth.”

Hill’s return is expected to signal a shift back to Nike’s core values—focusing on innovative products, storytelling, and leveraging key partnerships. Hill himself is optimistic about the road ahead. “Nike has always been a core part of who I am, and I’m ready to help lead it to an even brighter future,” Hill said in a statement. “Together with our talented teams, I look forward to delivering bold, innovative products that captivate consumers for years to come.”

A Time for Reflection and Rebuilding

Under Donahoe’s leadership, Nike faced criticism not only from within but also from outside analysts. Simeon Siegel, an analyst at BMO Capital Markets, noted, “Donahoe’s strategy to prioritize the DTC model over its wholesale partners was an ambitious but ultimately flawed approach. Nike’s core competitive advantage has always been its ability to excite consumers with innovative products and strong partnerships. The pivot was too drastic, too fast.”

The return of Hill brings renewed hope that Nike can regain its footing in a rapidly changing retail environment. Industry observers believe that Hill’s leadership will focus on balancing innovation with operational efficiency, ensuring that Nike continues to deliver high-quality products while nurturing its relationships with key partners.

“Nike lost the plot when it stopped listening to the athletes and its partners,” said Matt Halfhill, founder of Nice Kicks. “Elliott Hill understands Nike’s DNA better than most. His years working with athletes, retailers, and consumers put him in a prime position to bring Nike back to its core values.”

What Lies Ahead for Nike

While Hill’s return has been greeted with optimism, Nike still faces significant challenges. The company’s stock has been under pressure, and its innovation pipeline has been criticized for relying too heavily on legacy products. Moreover, Nike is grappling with how to remain relevant in a fast-evolving market where digital experiences and sustainability are increasingly important to consumers.

Hill’s leadership will be put to the test as he seeks to navigate these challenges while restoring confidence among Nike’s investors and partners. One critical area of focus will be product innovation—creating new lines that resonate with consumers and reinforce Nike’s position as a trendsetter in sports and fashion. Additionally, Hill will need to rebuild the company’s wholesale relationships while maintaining the growth of its e-commerce platforms.

As Donahoe prepares to exit the company, he leaves behind a mixed legacy. “It’s been an honor and privilege to be part of this incredible company, and I’ll always value my time at Nike,” Donahoe said in a statement. “It became clear now was the time to make a leadership change, and Elliott is the right person.”

With Hill at the helm, Nike hopes to return to its roots while adapting to the new realities of the global retail landscape. As Hill takes on this challenge, the sports world—and Wall Street—will be watching closely.