Jury selection begins today in Oakland’s federal courthouse. Elon Musk faces off against Sam Altman and OpenAI in a trial that could upend the AI powerhouse’s structure. Musk, who co-founded the lab in 2015 as a nonprofit dedicated to safe AI for humanity, claims Altman and president Greg Brockman betrayed that mission by steering it toward a closed-source, profit-driven giant backed by Microsoft. He poured about $40 million into OpenAI early on. Now he wants the jury to unwind the shift, oust the leaders, and redirect any winnings—potentially $150 billion or more—to the nonprofit arm.
The case narrows to breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment after Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers dismissed fraud claims at Musk’s request last Friday. That move streamlines arguments for jurors. Musk alleges deception from the start. Court filings reveal emails, texts, and Brockman’s 2017 journal entries where he pondered ousting Musk to pocket $1 billion, then backed off, calling it ‘morally bankrupt.’ Musk quit the board in 2018 after pushing for control, which others rejected. OpenAI says he knew a for-profit arm was needed for computing power and even helped court Microsoft over Amazon.
Altman texted Musk in early 2023: ‘i am tremendously thankful for everything you’ve done to help—i dont think openai would have happened without you—and it really fucking hurts when you publicly attack openai.’ On X, Musk fires back, dubbing him ‘Scam Altman’ and a ‘swindler.’ Altman recently told a podcast he’s eager to air it all out, fearing Musk might drop the suit pre-trial. ‘My fear at this point is he decides to drop the case right before trial, and we don’t get to do all this.’ OpenAI’s recapitalization last October made its for-profit side a public benefit corporation under nonprofit oversight. Too late, Musk argues.
Witnesses pack the list. Expect Musk and Altman on the stand. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella and CTO Kevin Scott will detail the partnership. Mira Murati, OpenAI’s ex-CTO now running her own lab, may speak to Microsoft’s role during Altman’s brief 2023 ouster and return—when the board cited his lack of ‘candor.’ OpenAI’s first chief scientist accused Altman of a ‘consistent pattern of lying.’ Ilya Sutskever, co-founder poached by Musk from DeepMind, could testify. Even Shivon Zilis, Musk’s partner and former OpenAI board member, and his aide Jared Birchall might appear. Bret Taylor, OpenAI chair, rounds out the tech elite parade.
Odds tilt against Musk. Prediction markets like Kalshi peg his win chance near 40-50%, down from higher bets earlier. Legal experts call him an underdog, testing novel theories on nonprofit governance in AI. The Wall Street Journal notes the suit seeks to claw back billions and boot Altman, but courts favor clear contracts over vibes. No ironclad founding agreement barred the pivot, OpenAI insists. Musk counters with oral promises and the original charter’s spirit.
Credibility hangs in the balance. A New Yorker profile last month, drawing on 100+ interviews and memos, spotlights doubts about Altman. Former colleagues whisper of manipulation. OpenAI’s 2023 board fired him partly over candor issues, only to reinstate amid chaos. Musk amplifies this, tying it to broader AI risks. If jurors side with him, remedies follow: judge decides on reversals, removals, disgorgement. Altman out. OpenAI reverts. Microsoft deal scrutinized. Ahead of a possible IPO, shareholders question his fit, per WSJ reports.
But OpenAI fights back hard. They paint Musk as a sore loser whose xAI trails. He launched a $97 billion bid for OpenAI last year, rebuffed. OpenAI urged regulators to probe his ‘anti-competitive’ moves, including wooing Mark Zuckerberg for the bid. Reuters covered the filing. Musk amended his suit in April to funnel damages to the nonprofit, not his pocket—smart optics. Still, Bloomberg sees him narrowing claims to survive.
Court documents spill Silicon Valley secrets. Washington Post highlights cringey texts and diaries. Brockman’s entries show internal power plays at Burning Man. Musk’s camp leaked a dossier questioning Altman’s character, per The Verge. Judge Gonzalez Rogers, known as tough on billionaires—once scolding Apple—warns against drama. New York Post dubs her ‘Judge Judy.’
Timing adds pressure. OpenAI eyes IPO by year-end. Altman juggles side ventures, seeking OpenAI cash for rivals to Musk like Stoke Space rockets, WSJ reveals. External threats loom: a Molotov attack on Altman’s home last week, suspect carrying an ‘Anti-AI’ list with exec names. Reuters reports attempted murder charges. AI fury boils over.
The New York Times frames it as an epic AI race pivot point. Musk wants OpenAI open and humanity-first. Altman chases scale. Jurors—ordinary Californians—decide if promises bind in tech’s wild west. A win for Musk precedents every nonprofit AI shift, from Anthropic onward. Loss affirms Altman’s path. Trial runs weeks. Stakes: control of AI’s future.
Musk grew up tinkering in the Midwest, hooked on tech young—like the rest of us who chased code before AI reshaped everything. Dogs? Man’s best friend through it all. This fight echoes that scrappy start against big shifts.
WebProNews is an iEntry Publication