Matt Rife Defends Sydney Sweeney in Ad Backlash, Sales Surge $300M

Comedian Matt Rife defended Sydney Sweeney against online backlash over her American Eagle jeans ad, accused of promoting racism and eugenics. Labeling critics "garbage losers," his viral post drew support from Halsey. Despite controversy, sales surged $300 million. This highlights how scandals can paradoxically boost visibility and profits.
Matt Rife Defends Sydney Sweeney in Ad Backlash, Sales Surge $300M
Written by Elizabeth Morrison

Comedian Matt Rife has stepped into the fray surrounding actress Sydney Sweeney’s recent American Eagle advertising campaign, offering a vocal defense amid widespread online backlash. The controversy erupted last month when Sweeney, known for her roles in “Euphoria” and “Anyone But You,” appeared in a jeans ad for the retailer that some critics labeled as promoting divisive ideologies, including accusations of racism and eugenics. Rife, himself no stranger to public scrutiny after his own comedy specials drew ire for insensitive jokes, took to social media to lambast detractors, calling them “absolute garbage losers” in a post that quickly went viral.

Sweeney’s ad featured her in casual denim, with taglines emphasizing personal style and confidence, but it sparked outrage on platforms like X, where users accused the campaign of subtly endorsing far-right sentiments. According to reports from New York Post, Rife’s intervention highlighted the comedian’s empathy, drawing parallels to his own experiences with cancellation attempts. He argued that the internet’s mob mentality unfairly targets celebrities for innocuous endorsements, urging fans to focus on the products rather than fabricating scandals.

Escalating Online Firestorm and Celebrity Solidarity

The backlash extended beyond the ad itself, intertwining with Sweeney’s other ventures, such as a bathwater-scented soap collaboration with Dr. Squatch that some deemed exploitative. Recent posts on X, including those from high-profile accounts like Daily Mail US, amplified Rife’s support, with millions of views underscoring the polarized public opinion. Entertainment outlets noted that while some users praised American Eagle for standing firm—no apologies issued, as per statements covered in AOL’s coverage—the brand reportedly saw a surge in sales, estimated at $300 million in a single day, per viral X threads.

Rife’s defense wasn’t isolated; singer Halsey, Sweeney’s co-star in an upcoming project, also slammed the boycotts, linking them to broader cultural tensions. As detailed in The Indian Express, this solidarity came amid reports of Sweeney’s film “Americana” suffering at the box office, potentially due to spillover from the ad drama. Industry analysts suggest such controversies can paradoxically boost visibility, with free media exposure valued at $65 million, according to sentiment analysis shared on X by users tracking brand metrics.

Industry Implications for Endorsements and Public Image

For insiders in Hollywood and advertising, this episode reveals the precarious balance celebrities must strike in an era of hyper-scrutiny. Rife, whose Netflix special “Natural Selection” faced similar uproar over domestic violence jokes, positioned himself as a kindred spirit, tweeting defenses that resonated with those weary of cancel culture. Coverage from TMZ emphasized Rife’s focus on the bathwater soap angle, arguing it was a playful nod to fan culture rather than anything sinister.

Sweeney’s response has been measured; in a recent Wall Street Journal interview, she addressed the noise indirectly, emphasizing her commitment to authentic projects. Yet, as Daily Mail Online reported, the ad’s tagline—”Her jeans. Her story.”—became a flashpoint, with American Eagle doubling down in statements that celebrated individual expression. This stance, rare in today’s corporate world, could set a precedent for how brands navigate social media storms.

Broader Cultural and Economic Ripples

The Sweeney-Rife saga underscores shifting dynamics in celebrity endorsements, where a single campaign can ignite global debates. Data from platforms like X shows a 4,000% spike in negative sentiment within 72 hours of the ad’s release, as noted in various user analyses, yet positive engagements, including from accounts like Clown World, highlighted the brand’s resilience. Entertainment Now’s reporting suggests Rife’s involvement may humanize the discourse, reminding audiences that stars are often caught in crossfires they didn’t ignite.

Ultimately, this controversy may benefit all parties: Sweeney gains defender cred, Rife rehabilitates his image, and American Eagle enjoys the publicity. As Entertainment Weekly observed, in an attention economy, even backlash can translate to bottom-line gains, provided the narrative doesn’t spiral into irreparable damage. For industry watchers, it’s a case study in resilience amid digital volatility.

Subscribe for Updates

BrandBuildingPro Newsletter

The BrandBuildingPro Email Newsletter is designed for enterprise marketers focused on scaling brand impact and driving growth. Perfect for marketing leaders aiming to build powerful, enduring brands.

By signing up for our newsletter you agree to receive content related to ientry.com / webpronews.com and our affiliate partners. For additional information refer to our terms of service.

Notice an error?

Help us improve our content by reporting any issues you find.

Get the WebProNews newsletter delivered to your inbox

Get the free daily newsletter read by decision makers

Subscribe
Advertise with Us

Ready to get started?

Get our media kit

Advertise with Us