Crypto traders face a peculiar bind this year. The IRS has handed out relief on how to track sales of digital assets held at brokers. Yet that same grace period sets the stage for conflicting reports between exchanges and taxpayers’ own ledgers. IRS Notice 2026-20, issued in March, pushes the temporary break through December 31, 2026. Taxpayers can stick to their personal records for picking which lots they sold. Brokers, though, keep reporting under their rules. Result? One trade, two versions.
Picture this. You buy Bitcoin on Exchange A in 2024, transfer it to Exchange B in 2025, then sell in 2026. Your software shows specific identification—highest cost basis first, say—to minimize gains. Exchange B reports first-in, first-out to the IRS via Form 1099-DA. Mismatch. The agency flags it. Auditors knock.
This stems from the digital asset broker rules ramping up. Gross proceeds reporting kicked off January 1, 2025. Cost basis joins for 2026 buys. Form 1099-DA captures sales data. Brokers must send it to taxpayers and Washington by mid-February next year. But systems lag. Relief buys time. It doesn’t fix the core clash, as noted in the Yahoo Finance analysis by Alex Shilina.
Active users hit hardest. Multi-exchange hoppers. Self-custody fans pulling assets out. Specific lot pickers. FIFO defaults if you don’t specify at sale time. That’s oldest units first—often lowest basis, biggest taxes. Relief lets you override with your books for now. Come 2027? Brokers’ word weighs heavier. Relief ends.
IRS penalties stay waived for good-faith 2025 efforts. Notices 2024-56 and 2025-33 cover that. Backup withholding too. But taxpayers report everything anyway. No 1099-DA? Still disclose on Schedule D and Form 8949. Box B for broker proceeds without basis. Box C for DeFi or unreported trades. Box A waits till brokers nail basis on post-2026 buys, per CountDefi.
And Congress stirs. Bipartisan push via the PARITY Act. Reps. Max Miller (R-OH) and Steven Horsford (D-NV) updated their draft in March. No gain on regulated stablecoin sales if basis tops 99% of redemption value. Exchanges get $1 basis. Staking deferrals up to five years. Narrower asset definitions. Trading safe harbors. Aimed at payments, not Bitcoin swings, as detailed in Sullivan & Cromwell tax memo and CoinDesk.
Still draft. Spring bill eyed. Reconciliation path possible—simple Senate majority. White House Crypto Council whispers inclusion. XRP, XLM types cheer. Infrastructure assets first in line.
Surveys paint worry. CoinTracker-Coinbase poll: 61% blind to 1099-DA. Half miss taxable events despite reporting crypto before, via Forbes. Greenback Tax flags the extension as vital for expats too, in their blog.
Tax pros urge action. Track across wallets. Use software syncing APIs. Document transfers. Specific ID? Note it timely per regs §1.1012-1(c). Losses offset gains. Up to $3,000 against income. Carry forward rest. No wash rules yet—harvest away. Donate appreciated coins. Fair market deduction, no gain hit.
But mismatches loom. Brokers report what they know. Taxpayers defend with records. IRS matches 1099s to returns. Discrepancies trigger CP2000 notices—proposed bills, not full audits. Ignore? They bill you.
DeFi dodges broker rules. No custody, no 1099. Self-report. Harder post-relief.
Relief helps. Yet it spotlights cracks. Traders must align books now. Or pay later. 2027 looms without fixes. PARITY or not.
WebProNews is an iEntry Publication