Read WebProNews
With Friends!

+1 Button From Google The Next Ranking Signal

Google's Detour Around Facebook Data

Get the WebProNews Newsletter!
Top Rated White Papers and Resources
There are 58 Comments. Add Yours.
  1. Thanks so much for mentioning Wajam, Chris! Just wanted to let you know that Wajam has extensions for Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and IE.

    • Updated to the broader “browser”. Thanks Alex.

  2. I really like the +1 feature better than like. It kinda makes better sense to me. Thanks for making things more adjustable.

  3. No doubt that +1 is a good idea as compared with the FB like but only time can reveal its extent of goodness.

    We sincerely look forward for better features in Google which we are sure that Google is soon going to launch.

    • Agreed. Time will reveal whether this was a good idea or not.

  4. This might be a big change of Google and can also challenge Facebook,but as people are becoming fan of Facebook more and more,it is a big challenge for Google also. While +1 would be the recommendation of content in the search results,the relevancy may not be as related as it should be with the search terms.

  5. As you mentioned with the purchasing of Facebook “likes” – this has the potential to be spammed heavily, especially since they have boasted to the world that this will impact rankings.

    How do you suppose they will stop it? I can’t believe the spam issue hasn’t been brought up in the mainstream yet. They’ve obviously put a lot of time and money into this system – there has to be some sort of spam prevention built it, but I don’t see how.

    Nice article!
    Allen

    p.s. the post contains to “you”‘s where there should be “your”‘s :-)

    • I was thinking about this a little more…

      What are the odds that a person, when doing a search and finding something good, is going to go back to Google and +1 the search result? The person found what they wanted. Why would they go through the trouble of trying to find the SERP again?

      Perhaps most of us, as advanced Internet users who are “in the know”, may try to do it – but most people don’t think about the Internet and Google like we do…not yet anyway.

      So in my opinion, this would increase, even more, the value of spamming this feature.

      AL

      • I couldn’t agree more.

        Of course, the +1 feature is a “nice” idea, a quick way to share/exchange preferences.

        I see some new good jobs PPB – Pay Per Button – Specialists coming >;P and this is not a good thing for the users, isn’t it?

      • That’s exactly what I was thinking. One way to get the +1 thing to work might be for Google to display the site the person wants to go to inside of a frame. And then, when the person leaves that site (or rather, page), they see a small notice that asks them if they’d recommend that page.

        But for this to be as valuable to the searcher as possible, it has to be integrated with Facebook data, since Facebook is the #1 social site.

  6. Google is certainly looking to index things faster and faster. Probably the spare capacity now they don’t bother doing page rank indexing anymore! That used to use up a lot of server capacity!

  7. A total flop!

    I have multiple Gmails, Buzz, Google Accounts… and therefore profiles. While you can only sign-up for the +1 in Google Labs under Search Experiment with one profile. The one I used I’m never on. Switch it to the Google Account I’m always on… I don’t have a Google Profile for that Google Account because Google won’t allow me to set one up.

    Google pretty much screwed themselves on this one. This flop is going to surpass Buzz. Yet another example of Google jumping into the pool before making sure there’s some water in it!

  8. Thom

    Sorry, Google, you are the old. Chin up, though, usually whenever anyone plays catchup their mimicing is just poor imitation like this. As Facebook might say, Buzz off! :-)

  9. It will be interesting to see how blackhat +1-ing will come in to play and what they will do to prevent. It’s just like hiring people in India to earn WOW gold!

  10. I think sharing will give search a + touch, like mixing FB with Google: that seems another big event by Google Team…

  11. Bob

    This will be very easy to scam.

    Pay Indians to jump from ip to ip, account to account, hitting +1 on your site.

    • Lori

      Agreed. Sites with quality contents will lose out in the search results ranking to those that employ this scheme.

  12. Thanks for the heads up Chris, at least now FB is going to find a direct competition.

    Unfortunately, using a french version of google so can’t see it yet. Who knows this may well be a good start for getting up the page for some

  13. +1 is to much like shopping. Clicking +1 will be like adding something to a cart somewhere. A call to action word would be alot better like “like” :) P.S. (where are the “hate it” buttons?)

  14. I do a lot of online marketing but lately I am getting sick of it.

    FB scrapping FBML pages for iFrames just as I was starting to like and use them, Google with their Panda dance…I think it is starting to get out of hand as these to start to do battle more seriously.

    FB and Google are getting like the two biggest bullies in the playground, each trying to outdo the other whilst increasing their “gang” as they go.

    Some things seem to be a little desperate with everyone jumping on the SEO bandwagon these days…for example:

    A friend of mine in the UK had a BT (British Telecom) engineer visit him last week, trying to sell him SEO services as part of the package ??!? My friend sells his OWN SEO services as part of his website building businesss. When the engineer left he actually admitted he didn’t like doing that part of his job and thought it was ridiculous.

    A quick Google search found he wasn’t the only one:

    http://blog.fluidcreativity.co.uk/bt-web-clicks-why-is-a-telecomms-company-selling-seo/

    As soon as you get used to one method of marketing, the big guns rip it up, create something new and expect us to join in their merry dance and of course, we have no option other than to oblige. I think Google are trying more and more to force us to use Adwords/Adsense and FB are gearing up for a paid service for businesses.

    As people have said before, these Goliaths don’t “owe us” anything, especially free traffic…

    It just seems like they are making us all integrate our businesses so deep within them that when they eventually charge us for the privilege (especially Facebook), we will have no option other that to hand over the readies…they have us by the ba**s.

    Lately all I do is run around trying to keep up with everything, chasing up people copying my work, fixing all sorts of cr*p and then don’t have time left to do my actual work…it’s becoming crazy online.

    As a regular surfer without my working head on, when I go to Google for info, I just want to do a simple search to find what I need without worrying about what my “social circle” likes. A lot of the time, even though they are friends, I have completely different tastes when it comes to a lot of things.

    All of this is IMHO by the way, I am tired and irritable today and will no doubt change my mind tomorrow!

    As Bob says, its just another thing for people to scam that we will have to clear up in a few months…

      • I understand that Chris, I have been doing this for around 6 years but it just seems that lately things are speeding up and getting a little out of hand.

        Just work harder I guess!

        • Not much you can do to stop it.

    • I could not agree more! – Every week there is something new lately and to try and keep up in terms of SEO is getting harder. The SERPS seem to be moving all over the place and I’m just waiting for the next update to screw up all the hard and websites over the last 5 years… but as you say we have no choice but to hope and go along with them!

  15. dave C

    it sucks.

    +1 means good, but what about -1 meaning bad? Worthless as it will be hacked by spammering advertizers

  16. I think the idea is great but maybe you could have +1s as its own profile with to do lists and and favorite products or favorite sites and services. It would have more specific results to specific catergories using googles +1s could show -1s for things you dont like, to warn friends not to use or buy specific products or items but everyone should be able to have a profile even non google profile members in order to have everyone participate and is that not the true goal.

    • Just to add to what i said earlier it would be intertesing to see other peoples to do lists and who they hired to do a certain job or service, for example Oprah used a certain company to do some service and its on her google +1s profile more people would be hiped up about hiring that company or buying that product it has potential to attract lots of sheep who love to follow others just to say, Oprah bought this or i had the same contractor who did Oprah’s house. people always want to feel they are a part of something bigger than they are. I think something like that could potentially be a frenzy for everyone.

  17. I think a ‘LIKE’ button is great for any site or search engine, as long as it lands somewhere so your friends can see it, why not? Stumble has one, google can have one too..and maybe in the future, I will make my own :)

    • Google has one that actually says “like” on YouTube too.

  18. Here we go again !! Google are about to give the big boys another tool to beat the little guys with. I am fed up of trying to get my sites ranked equally with the “big Boys”. The “big Boys” end up with the advantage of scale each and every time and very quickly work out how to turn these tweaks to their advantage. They will simply outsource the task of getting idiots to click +1 tabs on each and everypage of their overblown websites to make them look more popular and relevant than a single page website guy with 100% totally relevent and meaningful content which will now be relegated to page 10,000 in the search engines….Why dont google do something for us for a change !!

  19. seems like an easy thing to exploit by IM etc . Good concept but not good for ranking for you can easily imagine millions of profiles being created on google by only 1 person and creating large click groups.

  20. I think they google perceive this as a significant step but in reality I think the ratio between users and searchers – searchers = those that do not and most likley can be bothered setting up a uers account and users = those that will or have done.

    It would be interesting to see the raw data – how many searchs v usrers who search – not that google is likely to release this data.

    My guess is the ratio would be something like 8/92 92% being those who search that have not signed up for a google account

    What do you reckon

  21. I recorded a screencast video on my thoughts regarding it. I don’t think it will affect rankings in terms of top five listings. It might help click-thru rates of top paid search ads, if you’re logged in. I think they did a better job of integrating Twitter followers and comments into organic search. I think it’s one more thing we have to watch, but could be a waste of time to worry about now. http://www.youtube.com/bizwatchsearch#p/u/0/X5rf-DzPqi8

  22. I think people are looking for new RELIABLE ways to stay connected. The current mediums, Twitter and Facebook are great but tend to be overwhelmed.

  23. Azin

    Will fail as always. What is Google anymore? Google is past its prime.

  24. What an absolute joke. If Google take +1 into consideration on their rankings, it will be open to abuse beyond belief and will make Google a total mockery. This means every Indian webmaster in the world will dominate Google search results bar none, with all due respect, we all know how prolific they are at manipulation.

  25. I hope people uses it properly. This will increase the spam on the web especially from the Asian people. Google has to be very watchful before considering this as a ranking (SERP) factor.

    People are really smart. They will use proxies and other means to get the better ranking. This will also affect small/new blogs as they usually do not have authority or large readers base to get more +1 like.

    Do we have any code/script to implement +1 like button on our website?

  26. I think the +1 will make it for awhile and then fade away like most things over time. Google seems to have there hands in everything now days. Wow.

  27. Sounds lame, but then I always thought that Twitter sounded lame.

  28. That will succeed, but not in such a rate as FB’s Like button because FB left Google behind. To reflect their real success rate Google’s button must be 2+

  29. First off, I think it’s possible that Google can duplicate what Facebook has done…if the big G is smart about it. By smart, I mean not re-inventing the wheel too much. Facebook already has a pretty good thing going with its “Like” button, and we all know that “Likes” factor into how often and high up in the news feed content is displayed. I think as long as they don’t over-think it, it could be a very useful tool. One thing to look out for though, is how to keep spammers from creating hundreds of dummy accounts just to +1 their own content. Facebook is really strict about the number of accounts a person can have, and I think that cuts down on the possibility of abusing the “Like” feature. If Google can find a similar way to ward against spammers who will inevitably try to abuse the system in this way, they’ll be good to go.

    Next up, I don’t thing the +1 button will make Google Buzz obsolete either. I can “buzz” something without necessarily “liking” the content. It could just be an article or video that I’m curious about and want someone else’s opinion on it, or in many cases I find articles to “buzz” that anger me and I just want to vent about that. Doesn’t mean that I like or feel the need to “recommend” the content. The +1 button, on the other hand, would really only be used for content I like and am willing to recommend to others on a positive note. I can’t say that it’s how everyone would use such a feature, but that’s what comes to mind first for me.

    And as for the rest of it, I take the new announcement like I take anything from Google – take steps to prepare for it and be a part of it so that you don’t get left behind by your competition or penalized. I mentioned this on another post earlier that talked about whether Google uses ads on a page as part of the ranking factor: You must plan for all possibilities, actualities and eventualities when it comes to Google. If you do and something goes big, you won’t be left in the dust wondering how to catch up. If you do and something doesn’t go big, you’ve just improved your users’ experience a little. But if you don’t and something goes big, you’ll be in the worst place imaginable and by the time you catch up, Google (and your competitors) will be moving on to the next big thing.

    So my advice is to start planning on how you can incorporate the +1 button into your site and marketing strategy, and educate your readers or site visitors so that they can help you take advantage of it. That way if it ends up being here to stay, you’ll be in the loop and able to benefit.

What do you think? Respond.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>