John Travolta, who has been elbow-deep in controversy all year, has followed up all the rumors and web-speculation on his sexuality with a Christmas album, recorded with his old “Grease” co-star Olivia Newton-John.

The duo did a sequel to “You’re The One That I Want”, called “I Think You Might Like It”, and so far it’s been widely panned by critics who call it “odd” and “creepy”.

Travolta, however, doesn’t care about the bad reviews.

“My desire was to make This Christmas an intimate album, not something too ostentatious or showy. From the moment we decided to do this, magic happened,” he said.

The album has some famous guest voices, like Barbara Streisand and Tony Bennett, and proceeds from the sales go to charities chosen by Travolta and Newton-John. Check out the video below decide for yourself whether it’s worthy enough to be called a “sequel” or if it is, indeed, creepy.