Arcade Fire’s upcoming album, “Reflektor”, gave them two singles to work with for their “Saturday Night Live” performance over the weekend, and the band delivered spectacularly with a stage full of musicians and some creative makeup.

Of course, guest host Tina Fey couldn’t resist turning the group’s stage presence into a sketch with a game show in which she had to figure out which of the two people put before her was a new cast member and which one belonged in the band. Check out the performances below.

Image: NBC