Read WebProNews
With Friends!

Is This Google Algorithm Update Costing You?

Google Mayday Update Affecting E-Commerce Sites, Long Tail Traffic

Get the WebProNews Newsletter!
Top Rated White Papers and Resources
There are 137 Comments. Add Yours.
  1. It is tough to stay competitive for Search Results when the algorithms change. Then again, the goal of the SERP’s is to return the most relevant results. For Web based business, manipulating those results is becoming more and more difficult. You must also look at your total Marketing Plan and really work to incorporate other means to protect your revenue stream.

  2. After reading this and a couple other articles and watching the official video at:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJ6CtBmaIQM

    I still have some questions:
    * What is meant by “long tail” keywords? Numbers please – 1,000 searches/month? 100? 10?
    * Besides “have better content” are there any other suggestions for improving long tail searches?
    * What specific factors in the algorithm changed?

  3. The “game”, the give and take, the studying of one’s competition and extrapolating the results pages, knowledge of what we’ve done and what we see our competitors doing; It is not unlike competition in a retail marketplace. Sites lose rankings, and they take really significant blows to traffic, business changing blows, and people or whole departments lose their jobs. At the same time, it can’t be discounted that some other site took their place, and are now reaping the benefits as one thing continues to hold true. If you are on Page 1, you will get traffic from potential customers. To work to achieve this placement is a business decision, and, unfortunately, cannot be bought and sold like advertising. What we’re having to do is refocus our efforts on more marketing oriented activities, which has always been the “high-horse” description of SEO. The challenges will continue, and that’s the difference between owning a business, or taking responsibility for your client’s business’ livelihood, and having a job.

  4. Guest

    You seem to be making Google responsible for your business’ demise. However, I’m sure you were thrilled when they had you ranked #1. YOUR complete dependence upon them is what cost you. That’s not there fault.

  5. Guest

    You SEO whiners are a hoot! Break up Google? Get a life!
    If you think Google’s a monopoly, then obviously your your
    brain isn’t large enough to make a page rank properly anyway.
    Yes, Google is horrible because they get you customers, whine, whine.

    I hate tripping over your lousy trash pages. Thank God they’ve
    been put where they belong.

    Go game MSN or Yahoo or some stupid index if that’s all you can take.
    It sounds like the new algorithm has penalized certain techniques. Joy.

    (I agree with Mark of Search Squad)

  6. There are many updates every year, and this has been going on for years. This is nothing new. Every significant update some people start crying like babies and blaming Google. Things keep improving for me. So far I’m up almost 20% from last year’s revenues. More traffic and higher revenues. Put my first web site on the internet in January 1996 and things have been up hill ever since. My only ‘down’ year was 2007. If a site has good content, it will thrive. However, anyone who bases a business on the internet, particularly based upon ranking high in search engines, is taking a great risk. If you go down in flames, you can’t blame Google. You have to blame yourself for not doing what is necessary to stay ahead of the competition. I’m so tired of hearing people complain that Google isn’t ranking them where they think they should be it’s laughable. Year after year, web sites that can’t make it blame Google for their own failings. If someone chooses to make their living on the internet, they should know the risks involved and quite complaining when things don’t go their way.

  7. Jim

    Dear Guest (“Its costing us a lot”),
    Google owes you nothing. If you want to guarantee a consistently high ranking pay for Google Adwords.
    You’ve been content to get free advertising via free placement in search engine results for 15 years. If you are on brink of bankruptcy due to a Google index change then your business was not well-designed and resilient in the first place: i.e. you need a wider breadth of ways that people come across the site URL (e.g. URL in print media advertising; or tie-in articles with local newspapers where for example they report results on some relevant survey taken on your site) than 65% of people come across your site via Google searches.

  8. Autocrat

    Yup.
    I’m that unsympathetic.

    Sorry folks – but what parts of things like;
    * Unique
    * Original
    * Useful
    * Interesting
    Doesn’t make sense?

    The majority of sites that are likely to be effected are those with little/no original content.
    Those with mass Duplication.
    Those that simply copy/paste from other sources.
    Those that give nothing of value/use to Users compared to others.

    If you are basing your business
    a) on Organic Search
    b) on Content that can be found on X other sites
    then tough luck!

    The concept of Original and USeful, of Quality and Interest is Not New!!!
    It’s been banded about for Years.

    People need to grow up and start listening.
    There is NO easy money on the net!
    You have to invest/expend Resources.
    Either You learn – or you hire others.
    You focus on the User.
    You provide Quality and Usefulness.

    Providing the same descriptiosn as foudn on 1,200 other sites is Not Useful!
    (And lets face it … a description of 24 words is not exactly Quality either!)

    Pick yourselves up off the floor.
    Put your toys back in the box.
    Dry your eyes.

    Now get to work!

    Go and talk to your clients/customers;
    * ask them what you can do better
    * ask them what they hate about your site
    * ask them what would make them come back for more
    Go and look at your competitors.
    Look at the successful and the those soon to disappear.
    Then ask yourself;
    * what are they doing that is so good
    * what are they doing that is bad
    * what are they doing that is plain old ugly
    * what can I learn from them
    * what can I emulate
    * what can I do better

    And before any of you even think about whinging…
    … if you are not willing to make that bit of effort – do not expect to have a net-business that makes you money.

    Your choice.

    (For those of you that are going to do the work – best of luck!)

  9. Guest

    “I do blame a lot on the changes Google made since over 65% of our web traffic came from Google.”

    Maybe you should THANK google for the past revenue they have provided you. Things change in tech. Complaining because what used work no longer does is not going to help things.

  10. with all the recent updates my analytics show google is delivering much more traffic to the same pages. my competitors pages seem to have been downgraded.

  11. Really can’t see the problem. Do you really expect Google to stand still with their algorithm?

    In my experience, the constant changes they’re making on a daily basis has done nothing to negatively impact my position in the organic listings.

  12. google-not-the-be-and-end-all

    for the poster:

    ——————————————————————————————————————–
    Its costing us a lot

    We’re a small firm and competition is very fierce. Google is making it far too complex for the average Joe to be where he belongs in ranking. We have been around for 15 years online and always have been #1 organic in our area of expertise. Now? We’re ranked 4 or 5. It has had a horrible impact on our sales so much so that we are on the brink of bankruptcy because of a 20% YoY loss in revenue since 2008. I do blame a lot on the changes Google made since over 65% of our web traffic came from Google.
    ——————————————————————————————————————–

    your on the brink of bankruptcy – well don’t rely purely on google, geeze – not a good sound business model you have – dependent on traffic from google.
    What are you staff doing to get round this, since 2008 – that’s more than 2 years ago

    come on google isn’t the be and end all!!!

    think outside the box

  13. Guest

    Relying purely on natural search is ridiculous. It’s akin to expecting free advertising i.e. “I’m in x market, in y location, with z service, and I expect Google to promote me when a user searches for xyz.” It’s completely absurd. If Google is where your traffic comes from, you should think about advertising with Google – rather than expecting a static algorithm ranking system that you can exploit for no cost.

  14. Jamie Wilson

    If you gripe about the changes, ask yourself: why are they making the changes to begin with? It’s to make it harder to game the system. If you want to blame someone for your lost revenue, point your fingers at black hatters and other unscrupulous practitioners.

    I think everyone would be a lot more upset if all that came up on the first several pages was crap, thanks to the system-gamers. That’s what would happen if Google used a static logarithm. Think about it.

  15. Guest

    Guest who made the comment “Its costing us a lot” on 5.8.2010… a three or four position bump in search engine rankings DOES NOT create a 20% loss in revenue for you. Either you aren’t drawing repeat business like you use to, your product line has fallen stale, or the economy is to blame, but Google is not to blame. That minor of a position bump does not have that big of an impact.

  16. With so many black hat seo types who manage to take advantage of the system, it’s good that google changes their algorythym. It’s also good for legitimate seo companies to continue contracts with their clients.

    Do I like it? Not so much, but do feel it needs to be done.

    For the past few years, the only sites that were coming up in the search results were landing pages with adsense ads all over them. It would be nice to have “real” search results for consumers.

    If you’re on your game, then this shouldn’t be a problem for you. If not, then maybe hiring an seo expert will be in your future business plans.

  17. Guest

    revnue?

  18. I noticed my Google referrals really tanked for my online shop (http://www.pinkycrafts.etsy.com) several weeks ago, but though it was just by chance and I hoped that traffic from Google would increase. It hasn’t. Thank you for posting this article, now I know its not something I did! On the other hand, I hate knowing that its a bit out of my control :) Who knows, it seems that Google makes frequent changes, so perhaps this won’t last forever.

  19. I have not noticed any changes and as a matter of fact my site has done better this week!

  20. Rbo

    I think Google will be history soon. Those Adwords ads as first listings are going to kill them. Google is not a search engine anymore but a PPC engine. If you have top spot organic, you’ll see a decrease on amount of visitors to your site. Google has changed for the worst. It is time to promote and support Bing or Yahoo.

  21. Relying on Google rankings alone is risky business. Google is a monopoly. You need to diversify your traffic sources. Google rankings can change anytime. Google has no good reason to list one website higher than the other in search rankings. What ever results they display would be regarded as good enough. Most of the pages in the first 2-3 pages are relevant and one or the other is not necessarily the correct result to show at the top. Yet it effects your traffic.

    • Mozilla SEO Tools may be help for understanding Yahoo and Bing algorithms
      SEO http://www.resdays.com SEO Company Multilingual SEO Solutions

  22. Social networking plus SEO SEM and SMO Social Media Optimization and Multilingual SMO MSMO trade mark http://www.resdays.com may be future of SMO or DAO Digital Asset Optimization MDAO

  23. Hi there,

    Never forget the first rules in SEO: It changes all the time. So, Google has made a change, which is not the first one. Do the basics right and you will have a sound long-term strategy.

    Good unique content, links (one-way and link exchange), no keyword stuffing, and good promotion of your business.

    Once you got that right, you need to monitize your site. Use 3 to 4 or more income streams. I prefer google adsense and started a blog on Google Adsense Tips .

    Cheers.

  24. Google Algo will cost in the coming days as its destined to. I really feel that google must keep a watch on domain based keywords and not rank them as it is currently.

    If u want to come on top in 3 or 5 months beating competition then the easiest way is to buy a keyword base domain and rank for it. This must be stopped.

    The new design, the links the way of search would change the game of SEO totally. I would tell u guys to focus more on Social Real time coz that’s where everything lies.

  25. Mayday Victim

    @Autocraft………..

    Untrue: “There is NO easy money on the net!”

    I’ve been gaming G for years……….makin $$$ bills everyday and it was EEEEEZZZZZZZZ!!!

    And hey, it only came to an end like 6 days ago……G was way behind on this update.

    This is routine…….webmasters get smart, Google gets smart, webmasters get smart, Goo…..

    You get the point. Stop blowing this thing up. More innovations will come from the spammers to regain their long-tail shortly. However, i have turned a new leaf because i want to have real equity in my web properties for various reasons.

    Anyone who says no too making 100$ a day off 5 mins work obviously just does not know the method.

    I would also say stop being G fanboys and thinking cuz you were untouched by mayday that google has your best interest at heart.

    Google is a dangerous consuming animal that we have all been feeding for years…

  26. The issue is that Google nearly has a monopoly on the search engine market and is far too unpredictable.

    An example was a person who was ranking for the number one recently had “sponsored ads” placed above his site in organic search results, effectively pushing his site into fifth position.

    I understand that Google is in the business of making money but in the above example no matter how many backlinks from authority sites he had and how good his content was, paid advertising simply knocked him from the number one position.

    So, in a nutshell, it’s not just algorithm changes people need to watch for.

    Regards

  27. Luckily for us and our network of websites we have seen improvements due to the recent algorithm changes. I’ve seen so many small businesses get hurt by it though and I really don’t see why–they seem to have great niche related content. Hopefully Google gets the bugs out of this thing to re-rank their sites but I can only imagine how hard it is to have an algorithm that gets it all right in the first try…

  28. great I hope that this algorithm wont cost my site, that started lately to be visible.

    good article anyway

    al3ab

  29. Deference to article author , some fantastic selective information .

What do you think? Respond.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>