Will Personal Search Turn SEO On Its Ear?
Bruce Clay Talks Big Changes in Ranking Due to Personalization
At PubCon, Bruce Clay, Inc. President Bruce Clay presented at a session entitled "Top-Shelf Organic SEO" in which he discussed the approaching future of SEO as search engines evolve into more modern ranking methods through more personalized search results. Bruce was good enough to take the time to speak with our own Michael McDonald in a one-on-one interview about personal search, which can be viewed in the video below.
In this interview, Bruce elaborated on the concepts mentioned above.
Behavior Based Search
Bruce says that everybody who does a search will end up with different search results based on their prior search history. Personalization is going to be "web-wide" using third party cookies and things.
He provided a specific example of a search for "java". Some are looking for programming, some are looking for the beverage, and some are looking for travel information. Theoretically, personal search will know that and provide results accordingly.
"We can't search for any term and look at rankings because I can get different results than you for exactly the same query. So that's going to change a lot," he says. It doesn't matter if you're logged into Google or not. Bruce believes that Google personalized results will be coming out within the first quarter of next year.
Intent-based Search
Google has been looking up your IP and revising results based on IP. They know where you're located and can make assumptions about the intent of your search. As you get more into intent-based search, it's going to change the way pages rank, Bruce explains. "The page that ranks for a shopping query is an entirely different architecture than the page that ranks for a research query."
Where Does this Leave the SEO Crowd?
"Ranking is dead," says Bruce, recalling his words from his presentation. Going forward, he says you're going to have to look at analytics, measure traffic, bounce rates, action, etc. SEOs will have to ask themselves questions like:
- Did I get the conversion I was after?
- Did I really deliver on the promise of SEO?
Bruce thinks that in the first six months of 2009, we're going to see a lot more implementation of behavior and intent-based search leading to a mindset of "ranking is dead, and traffic is all that matters."
Universal Search
Bruce says this will be the most significant factor of 2009. Google looks at soundtracks and convert them to text. They can jump into the middle of videos, scan sites to determine if you have video/images or not. There are a lot of variables in universal search, and some of these variables tell how engaging your site is.
If you don't have video and your competition does, Bruce thinks we're going to see a big shift in rankings. He thinks if the top ten sites don't have video, they may lose their ranking over night.
Bruce notes that Google has been testing some of these variables, and will really start testing them a lot more in the first quarter, once the holidays are out of the way. He mentions the criticism Google took over the Florida Update, which took place in the month of November, and believes the company wants to avoid that again. He thinks we're going to see a lot of "Google Dances" early in the year though.
The Impact on Spam
According to Bruce, this is all going to really help Google fight spammers. He says it will affect the way scrapers and spammers work, because if they are just scraping text, they wouldn't be able to rank.
He also says that all of the variables that come into play may diminish the value of linking, which will certainly not help the spammers' cause either. He says it will be a big win for Google, and big win for the searchers.
There's no question that if everything Bruce talked about comes true, the SEO world will be turned on its ear. Bruce says, "If you're not ready for it as an SEO, you're gonna lose."
Who's Right: TechCrunch or Twitter? @biz says "we absolutely did not give permission for these documents to be shared"
-

Is Social Media Making Us Less Social Offline?
If you need to contact a friend or colleague, how do you do it? Do... -

Twitter Hack Sparking Security and Ethical Concerns
If you haven't yet heard, the popular microblogging service Twitter... -

Businesses Not So Eager for Windows 7
ScriptLogic recently conducted a survey to learn how businesses and... -

Twitter to Get a Nobel Peace Prize?
If you haven't yet heard, rumors really are going around about...
Expansion Accelerates in Chinese... NYT > World Business
Judge Dismisses SEC Case Against... Tech Trader Daily
Economy Won't Impede Obama Agenda, FOXBusiness.com
High-tech Toys Abound at the Tokyo PC World
iEntry 10th Anniversary
RSS
Newsletter
Advertising




















194 Comments
links london
great post,and you will lovetiffanys,
tiffany
Fantastic Video
Bruce you always make things easy to understand.
Cliff notes..
1) Goodbye Spammers
2) Hello Traffic!
As for the concerned SEOs... Evolve and adapt or find a new industry. :)
SEO
Fantastic interview. This all makes sense, but will it come to fruition before the end of the year. Google can move like a tiger or a slug ... which will it be in 2009?
Not bothered
My site is about evolution isnt science. How can that be affected by the new algorithm. maybe it can? Just im not sure how.
Still Waiting
I was just forwarded to this article by a worried client! I then noticed the date and have yet to see any of this happening in 'the first quarter of 2009'.
If it does happen it bodes well for the professional seo guys and will hit the spammers where it hurts...in the serps!
No biggie
As a seller of clotheslines, (the drying type) i can see people getting mixed up with clothes lines (the designer clothes type). All is well though, ppl will just refine their search and besides i doubt it will be as successfull so soon.
Im a big fan of personalized
Im a big fan of personalized search since it has come about as I find I get to things faster and generally find what topics Im searching on in a range of content formats. Video is a big one I enjoy.
I wonder how SEO will change
I wonder how SEO will change when Google finally implement all that changes into their algorithm.
my Visual Art Medium mainly
my Visual Art Medium mainly as Podcast on iTunes Store and a few episodes on YouTube. It seems a little too early to make the viewers understand that On-Line Video itself could be Visual Art pieces but I observe huge progress over the past few months. I look forward another huge leap in this area in
SEO mystery
Will thousands of SEO specialists loose their jobs soon? Google again makes them shiver. Google is always a mystery for SEO with its innovations.
Excellent
Excellent video.
http://search-engine-power.blogspot.com/
I think Google may just go
I think Google may just go ahead with this. It actually sounds like a good idea to personalise what we search for.
Why should the same results come up when someone types the same keyword. SEO is more about the traffic it generates than the rankings themselves. Someone might have a 1st place ranking, but isn't getting any traffic from it. It makes the SEO look good, but it's a waste for the site owner. I think this is exciting.
I think SEO was starting to get boring anyway. This will definitely add a little hiccup, but what's life without a few challenges!
but
how will change exactly, how are we gonna make the seo tomorow. i can see the change coming too, but i cannot see where the trend is leading to...
any idea?
Agreed too complex..
I have a heavy inkling Google will not go ahead with half of waht they say in rlation to this personal search. I hope they don't but I really can't see it happening at all.
Does anyone else agree wit me on this one?
yes,you indeed right. i,too
yes,you indeed right. i,too ,can:t see that.
It remains to be seen
Well, history so far has shown that each improvement from the search engines eventually gets less effective. There is no doubt that personalization will make spamming results much harder but I’m sure it will lose some spam resistance over time.
really liked the post
I really liked the post about seo. good post.
It's a matter of change
All the changes Google does will certainly change SEO but not kill it at all. Anyway there will be sites that suit Google algorithm better and there will be techniques that allow you to make your site look better.
Of course those SEO who don't change will be killed by algorithm change...
Another reason why rankings cannot be used as a SEO metric
Personalised searched is a good reason why SERP's cannot be used as a good measure of the success of a SEO campaign. Not everyone sees the same ranking positions and therefore traffic rather than ranking positions should be used to measure the performance of a SEO campaign
Engines will ALWAYS be beaten
People will always find ways around whatever Google do. It is in the nature of man to beat these things and once one does it, he spreads the word while making a killing and so it goes on.
"He provided a specific
"He provided a specific example of a search for "java". Some are looking for programming, some are looking for the beverage, and some are looking for travel information."
What is I am a programmer who drinks lots of coffee and wants to go on vacation in Java?
Wait and see
i dont think google changes its way of ranking completly. it can be tested and can give more priority in ranking but still pr will count too.
camera espion
Good news or bad news
well we wait and see. what the next from google. may be
I think SE personalized will not be excessive.
Internet Marketing Indonesia
Thank you
Thank you. I have benefited from this article.
Personal search seo
Search marketers must grow accustomed to working in more of a team environment in order to coordinate the creation and optimization of digital assets.
Personal search and seo
Mentality of people always changes . And Google is always coming with new methods which analyzes web pages for seo and spam and rank according to them .
When people search, they do
When people search, they do no t want results that are "smart results" - they want reality. Search results that encompass all answers - not filtered results. Why do people always want to train us into a world that they feel is best for us? If we are searching, we want answers - not predictable answers based on something else we searched for. That means keeping track of everything we were searching for previously - an invasion of privacy, in my opinion.
who knows what effect it
who knows what effect it will have? none from my end so far.
Personal Search
Let's not get into analysis paralysis... It only makes sense that if Google (or anyone else) can truly emulate the user experience in determining who (which web pages) better answers any web query... that is the technology that makes sense. If Google, through their user experience sampling, can better rank web pages within their databases... I am for that. Personally... IMO... IMHO... or whatever... I think the future of SE rankings will, at least for the top results, will be determined by user data... Accept or reject it... but that is the directions we are heading.
The reality of personalised
The reality of personalised search seems to be that its not going to make as big an impact as was forecast. It relies heavily, or so it seems to me, on somebody having typed exactly the same thing into Google previously, and the people most prone to do that are SEOs rather than Joe Public.
Post new comment