You can get in trouble for embedding someone else's wife, but embedding someone else's YouTube upload? (Waiting for the rim shot. Jerks. I get no respect).
A cease and desist letter sent by Doobie Brother Michael McDonald's attorney signals that just embedding HTML code of copyright-infringing YouTube videos on a website or blog could make you a target for zealous lawyers.
Though Ronald Lewis didn't actually upload the videos in question, he did embed the HTML so that the videos would play on his website. One could argue that makes his site a host for copyright-infringing material, even if YouTube is technically the host.
It is, after all, a sort of distribution, not to aid the lawyer sending the C&D's to Lewis, who actually accused Lewis of uploading the video onto YouTube himself.
In his blog post, Lewis seems rather defiant (maybe even a little melodramatic) painting himself as one who is bullied by legal gadflies. And he is being bullied, but the bright side is that it's just a C&D, and he can avoid legal action by removing the videos in question.
The issue here isn't, though, about how much attention the offended lawyer is paying to the details of the matter before he fires off nasty-grams, or even if Lewis is overly-righteous in his reaction.
The bigger issue is that this is the first many have heard of where a blogger has been threatened for embedding YouTube code. As TechDirt's Michael Masnick rightly (I think) predicts, this may be just the beginning:
But, honestly, the much more interesting (and rarely discussed) question concerns the liability of those who embed infringing videos. My guess is that it won't be long before we start seeing a lot more threats and lawsuits over embedded videos from bloggers who have no idea they're putting themselves at risk simply for putting a line of code into a blog post.
Ads Hit YouTube's Mobile SiteYouTube Launches Living LegendsComedy Central Gives YouTube OKYouTube 101, Just Because Warner Partners with Brightcove to Mimic YouTubeYouTube To Get Some Olympic ContentYouTube, CNN To Sponsor Democratic DebatesTurkey, Thailand Give YouTube More TroubleYouTube Continuing API PushYouTube Search Stinks, But Can Be Fixed
Comments
I have a very vague memory
I have a very vague memory of watching something similar to this unfold in an episode of “What’s Happening”…
I’m 32 now, so of course, I am much too young to have seen the original airing of that episode. It was the summer of ‘82 and I had just finished watching “I Dream of Jeannie” waiting for “Gilligan’s Island” (summer break re-runs of course on the local Fox affiliate before Fox was a real network). The tape-recorder down Re-run’s pants fell out while he jumped up and down after the final set….
After all of thee years and those poor Doobies can’t seem to get a break from pirates….
Post new comment