The X Factor Season 3 Premiere: Is the Third Season a Charm?

    September 12, 2013
    Shana Norris
    Comments are off for this post.

The X Factor Season 3 premiered Wednesday night to what some are calling disappointing ratings.

But Simon Cowell, who brought the show to the US from the UK two years ago, says he has it right this time. Cowell has said the current season is “the closest so far to the show we wanted to make.”

Season 3 features two new judges: Kelly Rowland and Paulina Rubio. They replace Season 2 judges L.A. Reid and Britney Spears. Another change: Mario Lopez will solo host without his Season 2 co-host Khloé Kardashian.

The X Factor came to the US in 2011, but the show had seen enormous success on the other side of the pond prior to that. The UK version premiered in 2004 and is still going strong.

Cowell said early tapings of Season 3 “definitely had more of the feel of the British show.”

Despite Cowell’s high hopes for Season 3, only 6.2 million viewers tuned in for the one-hour premiere Wednesday night. Season 1 opened with 12.7 million, and Season 2 with 8.4 million.

Does the dip in numbers reflect on The X Factor specifically or on a broader trend for television singing competitions? Ratings analysts will no doubt be weighing in on that after the September 23 premiere of Season 5 of The Voice and the January 2014 premiere of Season 13 of American Idol. Both shows consistently top The X Factor in ratings.

In the meantime, the Season 3 premiere generated some positive buzz on Twitter.

Host Demi Lovato is a crowd favorite, apparently worthy of her own #Lovatics hashtag:

Simon Cowell’s shirt even garnered a few words of praise:

  • Sara Mitchell

    It is not so much that we don’t like that style of show anymore as a country. The Voice is still fairly popular and American Idol continues to get high ratings (even if they have dropped a bit). Also, America’s Got Talent had a great summer with ratings continuing steady. It is simply that he picked a HORRIFIC line up of judges. Nobody knows who Paulina is outside of the Latino community and Kelly Rowland is simply a washed-up pop singer. She hasn’t had a hit song since Destiny’s Child. The only saving grace on that panel is Demi, and that is even cutting it close. She is too young to be mentoring acts imo. She hasn’t had much time in the business. Plus, Simon strutting around like the “proud papa” while the child was conceived while this “woman” was married to another man… DISGUSTING. Simon is no longer beloved by America. Take your baby, your botox blotchy face, and your gold-digger back to England and get off our televisions!