iEntry 10th Anniversary RSS Newsletter Advertising
Join the WebProWorld Forum!
Text: Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size | Print Print Article | Share: Delicious Digg StumbleUpon Post to Twitter Post to Facebook
77 commentsWednesday, April 22, 2009

What Separates a Blogger from a Journalist?

Bloggers as Local News Sources

77 Comments

I think it really depends

I think it really depends who you're asking because i've seen some bloggers that can provide in-depth content as it relates to the topic. Actually, some Journalists are bloggers. A friend of mine in presently living in the States as an intern for her Journalist career. She also blogs quite often. I think blogging is a good place to start if deciding to enter a career as a Journalist. Local search is a hot topic and many companies are positioning for the future growth. AOL snatched up Patch and some little companies that point local could be heading in the same path.

The difference is...

Bloggers aren't always under the same scrutiny as traditional journalists, nor do they always have the training or do proper research.

--

For PUA Terms and Acronyms - PUA Lingo

Blogs allow for more "connectedness"

I edit and write for a historical type niche blog and I find that the popularity of bloggers is on the rise primarily because of the interactive nature of blogs. Any newspaper worth its salt has to have a blogger on staff and keep up their "connectedness" with their readers. Blogs tend to have this intimacy edge over newspapers lending them more flexibility. This is perhaps the biggest difference in our world today between bloggers and journalists.

Blogs

The basic difference between the two is blogging is more informal and more of general subjects.

I am not a blogger who could

I am not a blogger who could never ever be classified as a journalist as my grammar is poor and my posts are probably amateurish but about 20% of bloggers are unlike me they are absolutely brilliant!!

I have read newspapers since I was 5 years old due to my Father being a newspaper man but they never thrilled me as much blogs do.
Blogs cover all my favourite subjects from politics to veganism and everyday I cannot wait to check in and see if they have been updated.

It can only do well, it improves the wrotten word by all and might even get more people to move from blogs to writing short stories or even a novels.

Accountability versus Independence

I like to think, as an established author, that my blog is both informative and governed by integrity. My aim, like that of a journalist, is to educate my readers by providing them with facts and advice which will help them to make rational judgements about their own lives, and the direction they choose to take, as well as about society in general.

But that said, I have to admit that much of my research nowadays is online rather than from published books and journals which have been scrutinised and vetted by a team of editors. This has to be the biggest failing of the internet, and the main difference between a blogger and a journalist. We are not accountable to anyone; they are.

I have long thought that the internet, powerful and wonderful though it is, may yet prove to be the next Tower of Babel. It makes gods of us all in that it enables us to be omniscient, omipresent, expert and independent. How long before our 'expertise' is shown to be diluted by misinformation, and the whole thing clatters down around our ears?

Blogger v Journalist

Bit of a two edged sword. But I think that the two forms of writing and reporting can and should compliment each other. Blogging is much more freelance while journalisim is more of a commitment to write for which ever news mogual is willing to pay you for your work. Both sides of the coin do have guidelines,rules,terms and legal requirements. All in all - It's whatever 'Tickles Your Fancy'.

It's been said before,

It's been said before, but it's down to accountability. As a journalist your putting your career on the line and putting your newspaper at risk. If your editor publishes your false or plagiarised story they could end up in court are at least have to print a public retraction.

The blogging community isn't under such public scrutiny and therefore uncensored, so they have more freedom.

I'm not in favour of changing it, as I love blogging, but if I we're a journalist I'd be doing everything possible to differentiate and protect my exclusives.

This is a very, very important discussion and I think could well end up in the courts with far reaching consequences.

It's ironic to say that

It's ironic to say that accountability is the difference, I've seen many journalists who print unsubstantiated inuendo and accusations and get a full pass on it. Accountability is neccessary, yes, but I don't think we have much of it in today's journalistic world.

FACTS AND OPINIONS

I totally agree with Zulfikar that Blogger are indeed write things on that they think about, their thoughts or opinion which is indeed a total biased compared to a journalist, because Journalist indeed make stories or report a news based on the facts that they have gathered with proves or supporting documents and indeed unbiased.

Two different types of "accountability"...?

I think the key difference is that print journalists are accountable before publication (i.e. they have to be able to demonstrate a sound research methodology), whereas bloggers are accountable after posting (i.e. they have to be able to fight their corner against hostile commenters).

These form two very different (but complementary) ways to fight your way towards some kind of truth (or influence).

Of course, the implications of this are (a) that a journalist who does not research properly is not really a journalist, and (b) that a blogger who does not allow comments is not really a blogger.

And I think we've seen enough of both of these. :-(

***I LOVE BLOGGING FOR OTHERS!***What about you?***

Great article Chris! I personally love to blog. I don't consider myself to be a journalist. I do however consider myself to be a "Blog Ghost Writer" for small and large businesses. It is a lot of FUN! It is even MORE FUN when I see that I am getting my clients placed HIGHER in Search Engines all from my blogging!=)

HIGH SEARCH ENGINE RESULTS = MORE WEBSITE TRAFFIC!!!!

I am an eBay Powerseller and specialize in
Search Engine Optimization Strategies and have been
offering my Marketing Services on eBay since 2006.
I also custom design websites and eBay Stores!

If anyone needs Custom Website Designs or
Internet Marketing, please come and see me! =)

Sincerely,
Tonya's Dynamic Designs
http://stores.ebay.com/tonyas-dynamic-designs?refid=store
*Follow me on Twitter at: http://www.Twitter.com/eBayHomeBizHelp
*Get FREE Website Promotion at http://www.WheresYourBid.com

Blogger vs. Journalist....My Site Was The Right Answer

I actually have a degree in journalism that has been absolutely of no use to me. For two years I have been begging newspaper and television reporters for their help in airing a crime. I have been turned away from every news outlet I have contacted. I have been at the mercy of journalists and reporters throughout this ordeal. Newspapers and television journalist and reporters pick and choose the stories that get reported and are notorious for excluding stories which they feel make them liable in any manner for reporting the story.

I desperately needed help in getting this story out to the general public, in an attempt to get these individuals prosecuted. I was repeatedly told that the story could not go public via any media outlet prior to legal documents being filed in a court of law. I begged and pleaded and those out cries for help always landed on deaf ears. Threats against my life were made repeatedly, and requests for police protection were refused repeatedly.

I created my site in Feb. of 2009. Since posting the story and all of the overwhelming evidence to my site, things have begun to look up. My site has been viewed several times by ATF, FBI, US Department of Justice, State of Arizona and Lake Havasu City local and Government officials. An investigation is finally underway after two years for Arson, Terrorist and Criminal Threats, Possession, Possession with Intent To Distribute, and on and on. If I had to rely on the medias help, I would still be at a stand still.

I was a journalist before

I was a journalist. Now the sales are very low and they can't afford to pay all of us. I decided a change in my career. Still my blogs are very popular among my fans.
In my opinion it's easier to click 3-4 times and read the news than going all down to buy the newspaper.

http://hhocarfuelcell.blogspot.com - Hydrogen Powered Cars - HHO Cell With Tap Water

Blogger write for FREE and Journalist not

1.What separates a Blogger from a Journalist? A degree and an institution to write for? I do it for free? I don't think we are all that different. Would you seek the truth from someone who gets paid or from someone who does it because they care and felt a story was important? I will say not all bloggers are good enough to be journalists and I don't think all bloggers are trying to be journalists. The bloggers that are good enough will stand apart from the rest and step up to this challenge.

2. Like webpronews.com I have right to put comment here bad or good and next commentator will decide and I don't think so opportunity to commenting article in newspaper where I don't agree at all especially where the source come in? Blogger have a digg.com or link popularity and great feeling when your opinion was digging and blogging by others bloggers in bloggers atmosphere.. Awesome yah!! we not alone.

Hyperlocal news

The BBC was going to do hyperlocal news in the UK, but it was ruled out by regulators on monopoly grounds. So it is complicated.

Accountability

Accountability

Ah, if only it were true.

Ah, if only it were true.

Accountability

Accountability

Accountability

Accountability

Online IQ and Importance of Having a Good "Filter"

I think most folks out there who have been reading blogs and blogging themselves are developing pretty good "filters" as to which of the hyperlocal folks in their area or areas of interest are putting out good quality stuff.

Chuck Welch, of Lakeland Local (Lakeland, FL) is one example. How do I know this? Because I took time to seek him out "off line" and get to know him one on one. This is the key. If you can connect with hyper local bloggers in your area in a live setting - you'll soon find out what they're made of.

Journalist = Facts (not

Journalist = Facts (not really since half of the news you see are ads)
Blogger = Opinions

Journalist v blogger

In my my opinion there is only one fundamental difference and that is; A journalist reports the facts as they where else a blogger talks about it from their point of view.

journalist = fact based
blogger = opinion based

Second Row Seat to History

Although I started my blog as a creative showcase, I became involved in conflict and commentary, and through that I've found myself drawn more deeply into related areas of study that lead to unique compilations of informations as well as encounters, finally, with primary sources. I have no advertiser funding and very few readers, but some of the referrals are interesting. Not too many writers put in their two cents about, say, the Pashtun, polio, and the Taliban in Pakistan.

As regards funding, I'm independent--a true citizen journalist--but while I may cover a local or regional event, I'm in no position to afford regular away-from-the-computer day and overnight travel. Producing that would seem to require institutional or organizational wherewithal or, alternatively, something like a grant-funded focus, reducing my posting frequency but perhaps far improving the quality of information making its way on to my blog.

Bloggers v/s Journalist

I am a good blogger (http://hindivani.blogspot.com ) and journalist too. There is no control on blogging and suppose if I have some personal opnion against Mr Barack Obama, I can write it with confort at my blog. But I file this for my newspaper I have to take responsibilty and accountability of that story. I think this is major fact which reflects that blogger will never take the place of a journalist.
Print journalism will never die. In India every year newspaper readers are increasing.

Blogger vs Journalist = personal view vs fact

I am a blogger-turning journalist. I think there less than an inch distance between a blogger and journalist.

the difference is that my writing as a journalist will relate facts with much of concern for bringing factual truth to people. while as a blogger, i put a lot of my personal opinion in it.

Blogger vs Journalist

I totally agree with Harris' comment. I am also a blogger turned journalist and the big different for me is how I present the material. My articles are much more fact related now. Blogging is all about personal opinion.

Blogging is still far behind journalism

I have seen many crappy journalists but I have also seen very few great bloggers who can be called 'journalists'. The reason for bloggers to fail - according to my standards - to be called journalists is simply because they do not write the stuff like a journalist, professionally trained, would do.

I am based in Malaysia and the biggest websites are still the newspapers despite the fact that some blogs and online news agencies (like mine) are thriving. The most popular blog on the Malaysian websphere is Malaysia Today and it still lack the journalistic flavor, the professionalism in writing and in exposing the subject matter. Most of the Editor's stories are blog entries and opinion pieces. Repetition in the stories are common on blogs and we do not see that even with the worst and crappy journalists in Malaysia for example.

When we compare blogs written by some professional journalists in Malaysia to that of ordinary bloggers, we can see the article formation, the story line and the suppression of the sins made by bloggers in such blogspots.

I think these separates the bloggers from the true journalists and it will take a long time for bloggers to learn to write like journalists in order to beat the newspapers (printed or online). It is a question of formation and perhaps, we should offer article writing and other journalistic courses for bloggers so that they can catch up with the profesional writers!

I have been a journalist for the past 30 years myself and my website is not a blog like people in Malaysia calls it since it is an online News and Analysis website!

bloggers/journalists

The difference is the search for fact-based truth. Journalists owe their audience the truth, no matter how they feel about the topic. Bloggers seem to have a more flexible approach to fact-based truth.

very well said

A blogger from Pakistan said to me, commenting on my news analysis piece on his country: Very well putted!

I would say you said it all here with your succinct comment.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
4 + 12 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Add new comment

SEARCH












Subscribe to WebProNews


Send me relevant info