Megaupload Takedown Didn’t Impact Piracy At All

The lessons Napster taught us still haven't been learned

Get the WebProNews Newsletter:

Megaupload Takedown Didn’t Impact Piracy At All
[ Life]

Clearly, the lessons that Napster offered about piracy all those years ago have yet to sink in with the authorities that are trying to “clean up” the Internet.

According to a study conducted by DeepField Networks, as pointed out by BGR.com, while the Megaupload takedown did have an impact on global web traffic, it did little-to-nothing to stem file-sharing traffic, web traffic that’s often looked at as the acts of copyrighted content pirates.

DeepField’s study is revealing on a number of levels, including explaining the amount of web traffic Megaupload accounted for:

As the largest file sharing service on the Internet, MegaUpload downloads represented 30-40% of all file sharing. In the space of an hour, Internet traffic globally plummeted by an astounding 2-3%. Press releases heralded a major blow to the theft of intellectual property.

That being said, whatever chilling effect the Megaupload takedown had was only temporary, if at all:

The main impact of the MegaUpload takedown?

Well, file sharing has not gone away. It did not even decrease much in North America.

Mainly, file sharing became staggeringly less efficient. Instead of terabytes of North America MegaUpload traffic going to US servers, most file sharing traffic now comes from Europe over far more expensive transatlantic links.

So that’s why Lamar Smith was so adamant about SOPA only targeting foreign sites. Clearly, he knew the Megaupload takedown was coming, and as a result, foreign web entities would fill the hole — almost immediately — that a seized Megaupload left behind.

DeepField also offers graphics to back up their findings:



Of course, as indicated earlier, these are lessons we’ve already learned when Napster was shut down. What happened then continues to be the case, as Napster clones popped up here, there, and everywhere.

Remember eMule and Kazaa?

Did the law enforcement agencies — backed by politicians who have been bought and paid for by the entertainment industry — actually think this would stem the piracy tide they are trying so hard to fight? Or was this a case similar to the drug busts of old? Something like what the Christian Science Monitor pointed out while reporting on a drug raid in Mexico:

Mexico seizes 105 tons of marijuana in Tijuana. Does it matter?

Considering DeepField’s findings, this kind of headline easily fits the Megaupload takedown and the overall impact it had on file-sharing piracy.

Megaupload Takedown Didn’t Impact Piracy At All
Top Rated White Papers and Resources
  • http://www.grputland.com/ Gavin R. Putland

    If the American jury thinks Mr Dotcom’s likely sentence is excessive, it can acquit him regardless of the “law” and the facts, and the acquittal is binding. It’s called “jury nullification”. But the jurors won’t be told this in court. They’ll need to hear about it from elsewhere. Spread the word!

  • badger_fruit

    The “war on Piracy” is as futile as the “war on terror”, pissing away millions if not billions of £££ which could be used for, oh I don’t know, making the world a better place for all the human beings who live on it and not just the “select few”

  • Join for Access to Our Exclusive Web Tools
  • Sign Up For The Free Newsletter